Marvin Windows vs Andersen Windows for New Home Builds: A Virginia Homeowner’s Guide

Choosing the right windows is a pivotal decision in any new home build or luxury renovation. For discerning homeowners and builders in Virginia, Marvin and Andersen are two of the most trusted names in the industry. Both brands offer exceptional quality, but their differences in materials, customization, pricing, and performance can significantly impact your project’s outcome. This guide provides a detailed, side-by-side comparison to help you select the best windows for your dream home.

In the heart of Charlottesville, VA, Commonwealth Contractors are established experts in installing high-end windows in new home builds. If you have any questions after reading this guide, please reach out.

Window Company Backgrounds: Craftsmanship Meets Innovation

Marvin: The Customization Leader

Founded in 1912, Marvin Windows has built a reputation for premium craftsmanship and bespoke solutions. Their focus is on high-end, custom homes and luxury renovations, making them a favorite among architects and designers who demand the best in aesthetics and performance. Marvin’s product lines are known for their attention to detail, extensive customization, and use of top-tier materials.

Andersen: Broad Appeal and Reliability

Andersen Windows, established in 1903, is renowned for its innovation and reliability. With a product range that spans from affordable to luxury, Andersen appeals to a wide spectrum of homeowners and builders. Their commitment to quality and versatility has made them a staple in both new construction and renovation projects across Virginia.

Product Lines and Materials: What Sets Each Brand Apart?

Marvin’s Collections: Tailored for Distinction

Marvin offers three main collections, each designed to meet specific needs and budgets:

• Signature® Collection: Features the Ultimate line (wood interiors, aluminum-clad exteriors) and Modern line (fiberglass interiors and exteriors). These windows are highly customizable and ideal for luxury homes.
• Elevate® Collection: Combines durable Ultrex® fiberglass exteriors with warm wood interiors, striking a balance between performance and beauty.
• Essential® Collection: All-fiberglass construction for maximum durability and minimal maintenance at a more accessible price point.

Andersen’s Series: Options for Every Project

Andersen’s product lineup is broader, catering to a range of budgets and architectural styles:

• E-Series: Aluminum-clad wood windows with extensive customization and premium finishes.
• A-Series: Wood interiors with fiberglass and Fibrex® composite exteriors, offering high performance and energy efficiency.
• 400 Series: Wood interiors with vinyl-clad exteriors, popular for their versatility and mid-range pricing.
• 200 Series: Wood interiors with vinyl exteriors, providing affordability with limited customization.
• 100 Series: Made from Fibrex® composite, these windows are durable, low-maintenance, and budget-friendly.

Material Comparison: Durability, Performance, and Aesthetics

Marvin’s Material Strengths

Marvin’s use of Ultrex® fiberglass is a standout feature. This material is known for its strength, low thermal expansion, and resistance to warping or cracking. Their aluminum-clad wood options offer a luxurious look with robust weather protection, while all-fiberglass windows provide a sleek, modern appearance and excellent durability.

Andersen’s Material Innovations

Andersen’s proprietary Fibrex® composite combines wood fibers and thermoplastic polymer, resulting in a material that’s both strong and sustainable. Their product range also includes aluminum-clad wood, vinyl-clad wood, and fiberglass exteriors, giving homeowners flexibility in balancing aesthetics, performance, and budget.

Material Comparison Table

‍

Styles, Customization, and Color Options

Window Styles for Every Vision

Both Marvin and Andersen offer a full suite of window styles, including double-hung, casement, awning, picture, sliding, bay and bow, and specialty shapes. This versatility ensures that your new home or renovation can achieve the exact look and function you desire.

Customization: Where Marvin Shines

Marvin is renowned for its extensive customization, especially in the Signature Ultimate and Modern lines. Homeowners can select from large sizes, unique shapes, custom finishes, and premium hardware. This makes Marvin a top choice for luxury homes and projects with specific architectural requirements.

Andersen’s Customization Spectrum

Andersen’s E-Series and A-Series offer significant customization, while the 400 Series provides moderate options. The 100 and 200 Series are more limited, making them better suited for projects where budget is a primary concern.

Color and Finish Options

Both brands provide a wide range of exterior and interior colors, wood species, stains, and finishes. Marvin’s aluminum-clad and fiberglass lines offer particularly broad color choices, while Andersen’s E-Series and A-Series stand out for their palette variety. For those seeking a truly unique look, Marvin’s custom color matching is a valuable feature.

Energy Efficiency and Performance

Marvin: Engineered for Efficiency

Marvin windows are ENERGY STAR® certified and offer high-performance glass options, including Low-E coatings and argon gas fills. Their Ultrex® fiberglass frames provide excellent thermal performance, making them ideal for Virginia’s variable climate. The Signature and Elevate lines are especially noted for superior insulation and energy savings.

Andersen: Innovative Glass and Composite Solutions

Andersen’s windows also meet ENERGY STAR® standards, with advanced glass options like Low-E4®, SmartSun™, and HeatLock® coatings. The Fibrex® composite material in the 100 Series and A-Series delivers strong insulation and durability, helping to keep homes comfortable year-round.

Warranty and Long-Term Value

Warranty Coverage: Peace of Mind for Homeowners

Both Marvin and Andersen offer robust warranties, reflecting their confidence in product quality. Marvin provides a 20-year glass warranty and a 10-year product warranty across its collections. Andersen matches this with a 20-year glass warranty and a 10-year parts warranty for most series. Always review specific terms for your chosen product line to ensure you’re fully protected.

Pricing: Investment Levels for Every Project

Marvin: Premium Quality, Premium Price

Marvin’s Signature Collection is positioned at the high end, with windows typically ranging from $1,000 to $2,500 or more per unit. The Elevate Collection offers a mid-range option ($700–$1,500 per window), while the Essential Collection provides affordability without sacrificing durability ($500–$1,200 per window).

Andersen: Broad Range for Varied Budgets

Andersen’s E-Series and A-Series are also premium-priced ($900–$2,500+ per window), but the 400 Series ($600–$1,500), 200 Series ($400–$1,000), and 100 Series ($300–$900) make Andersen accessible for a wider range of projects. This flexibility is especially valuable for large new builds or phased renovations.

Ideal Use Cases and Architectural Styles

Marvin: The Choice for Custom and Luxury Homes

Marvin windows are ideal for custom homes, luxury residences, historic renovations, and modern architecture. Their extensive customization and premium finishes make them a favorite among Virginia’s high-end builders and homeowners who want to make a statement.

Andersen: Versatility for Every Home

Andersen’s broad product range suits everything from affordable renovations to high-end custom builds. Their reliability and value make them a popular choice for both new construction and replacement projects across the state.

Pros and Cons: Weighing Your Options

‍

Marvin Windows: Premium Craftsmanship and Customization

Marvin’s strengths lie in their exceptional craftsmanship, premium materials, and nearly limitless customization. These windows are built to impress and perform, but the higher price point may not fit every budget.

• Pros: Superior customization, premium finishes, strong energy efficiency, and durability.
• Cons: Higher cost, fewer budget-friendly options.

Andersen Windows: Range, Reliability, and Innovation

Andersen’s appeal is in its broad product range, innovative materials, and strong brand reputation. While their premium series can be expensive, the availability of more affordable lines makes Andersen a flexible choice for many projects.

• Pros: Options for every budget, innovative Fibrex® material, reliable performance.
• Cons: Limited customization in lower-end series, premium lines can be costly.

How to Choose: Key Considerations for Virginia Homeowners

Project Type and Architectural Style

For luxury custom homes or historic renovations, Marvin’s Signature or Elevate collections offer unmatched customization and elegance. If your project requires a balance of quality and value, Andersen’s 400 or 200 Series may be the right fit. Modern builds may benefit from Marvin’s Modern line or Andersen’s A-Series for their clean lines and high performance.

Budget and Long-Term Value

Consider not just the upfront cost, but also the long-term value. Marvin’s higher price tag is offset by superior materials and finishes, while Andersen’s range allows for strategic allocation of your budget across different areas of your home.

Energy Efficiency and Maintenance

Both brands offer excellent energy efficiency, but Marvin’s Ultrex® fiberglass and Andersen’s Fibrex® composite provide unique advantages in durability and thermal performance. Maintenance needs are minimal for both, but all-fiberglass or composite options are especially low-maintenance.

Partner with Commonwealth Contractors for Expert Window Selection and Installation

Choosing between Marvin and Andersen windows is a significant decision for your new home build or luxury renovation. At Commonwealth Contractors, we guide Virginia homeowners through every step of the process—from product selection to expert installation. Our team’s experience with both brands ensures your windows will not only look stunning but also perform flawlessly for years to come.

• Personalized consultations to match your vision, budget, and architectural style
• Access to the latest Marvin and Andersen products and finishes
• Meticulous installation by skilled professionals
• Commitment to quality, energy efficiency, and customer satisfaction

Ready to elevate your new home with the perfect windows? Contact Commonwealth Contractors today to schedule your consultation and discover how our expertise can bring your dream home to life with Marvin or Andersen windows.